Rum—an intoxicating spirit born of sugarcane, sun, and history—has enchanted palates for centuries. Yet, within this vast ocean of Caribbean amber, a select few stand out: the crème de la crème that define excellence.

The Pinnacle of Rum Craft

• Foursquare Distillery (Barbados): At the top of the world’s rum rankings sits Foursquare 14 YO “Equipoise” (61% ABV), scoring a near-perfect 99 out of 100 on the 2024 International Wine & Spirit Competition (IWSC). Foursquare also earned Double Golds for its Covenant 18 YO and 2011 blend, which scored 98/100—cementing its place among the most revered rums globally (Forbes).
• Global Spirit Masters Awards: Worthy Park Estate White Overproof Rum (Jamaica) clinched the title of top rum overall; its unapologetic power and tropical fruit funk make it a standout. In lighter categories, Ten to One White Rum (Dominican–Jamaican blend), Pampero Selección 1938, and Plantation Gran Añejo excelled in taste and craftsmanship (Forbes).
• Beverage Testing Institute 2023: Kuleana Rum Works (Hawaii) Hokulei Aged Rum topped the “aged more than three years” category. It’s a gorgeous blend of multi-country molasses rums with sucrecane agricole, layered with pineapple, toffee, and green banana flavors (Forbes).
• Top Sipping Rums (Serious Eats): This curated list includes iconic sippers like Zacapa 23 (Guatemala), Plantation 20th Anniversary XO (rarely seen but widely admired), Flor de Caña 12, Ron Abuelo 12, El Dorado 15 (Guyana), Santa Teresa 1796 (Venezuela), and Appleton Estate 12 YO (Jamaica) (Serious Eats).
• Popular Premium Picks (Liquor.com): Mount Gay Black Barrel stands out as the best overall rum—balanced, complex, affordable, and versatile for sipping or mixing (Liquor.com).
• Broad Appeal Brands (Tasting Table): The top brands include (in descending popularity): Ron Zacapa, Appleton Estate, El Dorado, Pusser’s, Don Papa, Havana Club, Captain Morgan, Mount Gay, Malibu, Don Q, Kraken, Goslings, Angostura, and Sailor Jerry(Tasting Table). This list reflects both widespread appeal and quality across styles.

---

Castaways Cove—Rum from the Rockies

Now, contrast that with the spirited scene at Castaways Cove—a tiki-style haven perched high in the Rockies, where fun and flavor reign supreme.

Signature sips on the menu include:

• Mai Tai crafted with Appleton Estate rum—a classic Jamaican base woven with orgeat and curaçao (Toast).
• Jungle Bird, featuring a proprietary House Rum Blend #4, Campari, and tropical flavors (Toast).
• Piña Colada, built on rum and creamy coconut goodness (Toast).
• Add-on: Overproof rum float (like OFTD) atop any cocktail for an extra kick (Toast).

Castaways also offers Plantation 3 Star Rum to go, suggesting they keep some quality rum staples stocked (Toast).

Guests often praise both the atmosphere and the rum selection:

“This ‘World’s Highest Tiki Bar’ … Good rum selection there.”
“Some folks go to Breck to ski… I go to sip tiki drinks at CC.” (Reddit)

---

Side-by-Side: Elite Rums vs. Castaways Cove

Aspect	World’s Top Rums	Castaways Cove
Quality & Prestige	High artisanal craftsmanship; award-winning aged expressions (e.g., Foursquare, Zacapa, El Dorado)	Focused on approachable, fun tiki cocktails with quality rum bases like Appleton and Plantation
Sipping Experience	Ideal for savoring neat or on the rocks—complex, layered, refined	Mainly crafted for cocktails—designed for flavor, freshness, and fun
Rarity & Craft	Often rare and aged—meant for collectors and connoisseurs	Readily available blends optimized for balanced cocktail enjoyment
Setting & Vibe	Lounge, tasting bar, or bar cart at home—centered on spirit appreciation	Playful, tropical escape in the mountains—vibes over vertical complexity

---

Final Take

The “best 40 rums in the world” represent the epitome of distilling artistry—old-age expressions, bold overproofs, and nuanced blends for dedicated rum lovers. These bottles tell stories of terroir, time, and tradition.

In contrast, Castaways Cove brings rum back to its lively, communal root: fun, flavors, and flair. Their use of respected rum bases (like Appleton and Plantation) ensures quality, even if the experience isn’t about complexity so much as escapism.

So whether you’re a rum purist chasing vintages or a tiki aficionado chasing good times, there’s a place and a pour for every palette.

---